Skip to main content

The following collection details the cases Bushrod encountered while serving on the Circuit Court of the United States for the Third Circuit between 1803 and 1829. The Third Circuit consisted of the District of New Jersey and the District of Eastern Pennsylvania. Bushrod rode circuit to these courts for both a fall and spring term. He corresponded frequently with Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story, and their discussions helped both justices determine difficult legal applications and interpretations. Many of these cases involved bankruptcy, copyright, criminal, maritime, and patent law.

From Joseph Story, 8 Aug. 1826

Author

My dear Sir

I owe you an apology for my long silence & especially as I have two letters of yours unanswered. My Cirt. did not end until the latter part of June, & I have ever since been overwhelmed with pressing private or public concerns, which have obliged me to postpone all other business. In addition to my other labours I have been obliged to prepare a Discourse to be delivered this month before a Literary society (the P. B.

To John Bradford Wallace, 24 Dec. 1816

Dear Sir

     I have read over all the cases in my note books to the end of the fall term of 1809, with some attention, and now enclose you some observations upon such of the cases as seemed to merit criticism. You will observe that the corrections which I have suggested are principally such as qualify expressions more general than it was safe to use, or tend to expunge dicta which were unecessary to the points decided, the correctness of which might be doubted.

To Joseph Story, 25 Nov. 1824

Recipient

My dear Sir

I returned home two or three days ago, after an absence of more than 3 months, when I had the pleasure to recieve from the post office your very friendly and interesting letter of the 2d Septr— For your kind & affectionate wishes for my health I am sincerely grateful to you, as I am for some other expressions which I owe chiefly to your indulgence & partiality. my health is now, thank God, as good as it has been for some years past.

To Joseph Story, 21 May 1827

Recipient

My dear Sir

As Mr Sparks will probably leave this in a few days for Boston, I have determined, altho but half settled at home after an absence of 4 or 5 months, to prepare my letter to you that it may be ready for him to take on. The tea cause employed so great a part of the court at Phila. that few others could be tried before the Session came to a close.

To Joseph Story, 28 Sept. 1827

Recipient

My dear Sir

Your favor of the 25th inst., recd today, induces me to do immediately what I had mentally arranged to do after my return from Trenton—answer your interesting letter of the 4th July. But first allow me to excuse myself from the censure to which I am apparently obnoxious for having postponed the performance of this duty to this late day. I took that letter out of the office in Alexa.

To Joseph Story, 30 Nov. 1827

Recipient

My dear Sir—

It is about a week since I returned home, the session of the Phila. Court having been abridged by a severe rheumatic attack, which confined me to the house for many days prior to my departure. I have seldom, on any circuit, tried so few cases as on the last, and few of them were either new or difficult.  Such as are at all interesting, I will now proceed to state.

To Joseph Story, 26 Nov. 1828

Recipient

My dear Sir

There were so few cases of importance decided at my spring circuit, that I thought it would be best to wait for the fall Sessions, and to give you the whole in one letter. This task it is now my intention to perform. Some of the points decided are involved in much difficulty, upon which I shall be much pleased to see your observations.

From Joseph Story, 2 Jan. 1814

Author

Dear Sir

I have just closed a very laborious autumnal circuit, in the course of which many highly important questions have been decided— I would send you an abstract of them, if I could command leisure just now; but my whole attention is directed to affairs connected with my departure for Washington— I shall however either bring the original opinions with me; or an abstract per your use.

To Samuel Lewis Southard, 1 Feb. 1822

     I recd yesterday, at this place, your favor of the 30th Ulto.— Had it come to hand before I left Mount Vernon, it is highly probable I could have found amongst my papers a rough Copy of the two opinions in the case of Miller vs Mitch— it is now too late to have the search made. These opinions however are copied into my note book volume 17 which is in the hands of Mr Richard Peters Junr of Philadelphia, who, I think it likely, will attend this supreme Court.

Subscribe to Discussions of Circuit Court Cases