Skip to main content

The following collection details the cases Bushrod encountered while serving on the Circuit Court of the United States for the Third Circuit between 1803 and 1829. The Third Circuit consisted of the District of New Jersey and the District of Eastern Pennsylvania. Bushrod rode circuit to these courts for both a fall and spring term. He corresponded frequently with Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story, and their discussions helped both justices determine difficult legal applications and interpretations. Many of these cases involved bankruptcy, copyright, criminal, maritime, and patent law.

To Joseph Story, 19 June 1821

Recipient

My dear Sir—

I returned from my Circuit yesterday after an absence of 3 months wanting as many days. I was ten weeks in Court without intermission, and have upon no former occasion had so many important cases to decide. Notwithstanding the length & severity of this tour of duty, my health, thank God, has continued to improve, and I now feel as well as I have been for some years past.

To Joseph Story, 9 Aug. 1821

Recipient

My dear Sir

Yesterday was the first day that I was at liberty to read your letter of the 19th July with the attention it deserved, and to look into a few Cases. I regret that is not in my power to devote more time1 in examining the authorities before returning you an answer; but this is prevented by the necessity I am under of leaving home in a day or two for the Springs, whence I shall proceed on my circuit.

To Joseph Story, 18 Nov. 1822

Recipient

My dear Sir

Before I proceed to business, I must account for my long but involuntary silence. During the second day of the April term of this Court, I was, whilst on the Bench, attacked by a violent pleuresy which terminated the Session, as it had nearly done the life of your friend. I anticipated that event myself, as did most of my friends.

To Joseph Story, 11 Sept. 1823

Recipient

My dear Sir

Your letter of the 11th July found me upon a bed of sickness, from which I was not very soon relieved. I had scarcely become convalescent, before others of my family were taken down— finally, I determined to abandon the Country, which was becoming universally sickly, and to take refuge with Mrs W. in this place, which has, thus far, been unusually healthy. I trouble you with this account of my past troubles, as it furnishes the only legitimate apology for my long Silence since the rect of your favor.

To Joseph Story, 1 Oct. 1825

Recipient

My dear Sir

I owe you an apology for not having returned an earlier answer to your letter of the 20th June. The truth is, that at the time I recd it, and another from brother Thompson, I was engaged in a piece of business which required dispatch, & which induced me to postpone my answers to a period when it would be more in my power to reflect upon the decisions which you & he had made & to examine cases. But before that period had arrived our domestic misfortunes commenced.

From Joseph Story, 9 Dec. 1826

Author

My dear Sir

It has given me inexpressible pleasure to receive a letter from you; for the newspaper statement of your indisposition led me to fear that you were quite ill— I rejoice that you are so much recovered; & I trust, that a good Providence will enable you to join the Supreme Court at Washington, where your presence is so important to the public, & withal so interesting to myself.

To John Bradford Wallace, 5 Nov. 1808

Dear Sir

     I have Just read over the Case of Sperry vs. DE Ins. Co. & find it as all my notes of cases must necessarily be from the hurry in which they are made, extremely inaccurate in Style & in everything but substance. I trust therefore that you will consider my report of this as of all other cases nothing more than rough notes, to be corrected & reformed in your own way[.] If I did not calculate upon these corrections, I should not suffer copies to be taken until I could find time to transcribe then.

Subscribe to Discussions of Circuit Court Cases