Skip to main content

“This was an action on two policies; one on the Monongahela Farmer, and the other on her cargo, from New-York to Gibraltar; the former a valued, and the latter an open policy. The vessel sailed on the voyage insured, and was seized by two Spanish privateers, in the Gut of Gibraltar, and carried into Algesiras, where attempts were made to condemn her cargo, but without success; the cargo consisting of articles in general contraband of war, but within the exceptions of the treaty between Spain and the United States. The government consented, that the captain should depart, upon his giving security, not to carry the cargo to any British Port in the Mediterranean. The supra-cargo, under these circumstances, considering it most for the advantage of all concerned, to dispose of it a Algesiras, procured this to be done, under an order from a judge; and the sales amounted to about half the sum insured on it. The detention produced by tins step, kept the vessel at the port of Algesiras, from about the 13th of May, till the 17th of July; during which time, the supra-cargo, by means of a credit, which the plaintiff had given him, on certain merchants there, purchased a brig and cargo, and sent her to the United States. About the 17th July, he went with the Monongahela Farmer, to Malaga, where he took in a cargo of wines, on freight to New-York; but she was lost, returning to the United States . . . The company refused the abandonment of the vessel; and, considering the refusal of the plaintiff to make a cession, as a waiver of his abandonment of the cargo, they declared themselves exonerated from their former acceptance of it, and refused to pay the loss on the vessel or the cargo.”

Case Citation

1 Wash. C. C. 400