“This is an action brought upon a bill of exchange drawn by the defendant, on the 10th of May 1811, at St. Barts, for value received there, in favour of the plaintiff, on himself, at Philadelphia, 90 days after sight, which was regularly noted for non-acceptance, and protested for non-payment. This action was brought on the 4th of May 1812; to which the defendant pleaded in bar, his discharge, under a law of this state, passed on the 13th of March 1812, for the relief of insolvent debtors; obtained provisionally on the 23d of April, and finally on the 29th of May 1812. The case agreed, states, that the defendant did not give to the plaintiff, or to any agent of his, notice of the defendant’s petition, which was presented on the 20th of April 1812, although the plaintiff’s attorney was informed of the application a few days after it was made; nor has the plaintiff proved his debt under the said proceedings.”